Are Tesco, Sainsbury’s and Morrisons ready for Brexit?
A no-deal Brexit threatens severe disruption for UK supermarkets. But are some better prepared than others? We have a look at how Brexit could impact Tesco, Sainsbury's and Morrisons.
‘One can say very clearly what the direction will be: higher prices, less choice, and poorer quality, because all of those dimensions have been improved by these open trading relationships that we've had over the last 40 years […] Brexit, almost in whatever version it is, will introduce friction, it will introduce barriers. That makes it less efficient, which means all three of those benefits — price, quality, and choice — go backwards,’ Justin King, former chief executive officer (CEO) of Sainsbury's (2017).
The Big Four supermarkets were already up against it before Brexit, but the UK’s impending departure from the EU poses a huge challenge to the industry. The market share of Tesco, Sainsbury’s, Walmart-owned Asda and Morrisons is being slowly eroded by discounters Aldi and Lidl, and the pair’s relentless focus on price has also obliterated their margins. Now, with Brexit pencilled in at the end of October and the likelihood of a no-deal growing, they are threatened with severe supply chain disruption and higher costs. Meanwhile, consumers could face less choice, lower quality and higher prices.
We have a look at how Tesco, Sainsbury’s and Morrisons have prepared for Brexit.
Tesco and Brexit
Tesco has won applause for its turnaround under CEO Dave Lewis, who took over in 2014 following an accounting scandal. It is by far the largest supermarket in the UK with around 27% of the market, way ahead of Sainsbury’s 15% and Morrison’s 10%. It also has other characteristics that should help it mitigate the risks of Brexit, such as its buying power and international exposure.
Booker and Carrefour boosts Tesco buying power
Tesco has gained huge scale in recent years. Its decision to buy Booker and diversify into the wholesale business has been successful. Booker delivered 3.1% like-for-like growth in the first quarter of 2019 compared to the 0.8% lift seen in supermarket sales in the UK and Ireland. This has not only provided greater buying power but a higher-growth, higher-margin business.
It’s also signed a buying agreement with Carrefour, which is Europe’s largest retailer. The partnership means they can exert more pressure on their suppliers, giving it greater ability to force them to burden any cost increases from Brexit.
According to Barclays, ‘any outcome other than a full Customs Union will see additional costs imposed on the overall food supply chain’. The bank says, if standard tariffs were applied after a no-deal Brexit, then the average tariff on food and drink supply chains would be 27% - significantly higher than the average 3-4% applied to non-food sectors.
The tariffs applied to finished goods, those that are immediately ready to put on the shelves, is expected to be higher than goods that are bought in bulk and then readied for sale in the UK, such as milk or tea. This places the burden of new tariffs on the supermarkets at the end of the supply chain. The sums are serious too. An analysis by Barclays based on the UK’s imports during the 12 months to the end of May 2018 suggests new tariffs on food and drink imported from the EU could amount to a staggering £9.3 billion per year.
The question is: who will absorb any increases in the cost of sourcing food and drink? Will the supermarket swallow up the cost, pass it on to the consumer, or force it upon their suppliers?
The severe drop in the value of the pound after the 2016 referendum led to a dispute between Tesco and Unilever. The consumer goods giant was pressuring the supermarket to raise prices of its products to offset the weakness in sterling, but Tesco fought back because it didn’t want to raise prices for consumers.
Importantly, Tesco and Carrefour are predominantly purchasing the stuff they need to make their own-label produce under the partnership, allowing them to offer products that can rival those offered by the likes of Unilever in an attempt to cut out the middleman.
Wholesale arm also provides international exposure
In the past, Tesco has not earned a good track record outside of the UK after it was forced to retreat from the US and Japanese markets in 2012. Still, it operates profitable businesses in the likes of Ireland (part of the UK segment), eastern Europe, Malaysia, Thailand, India and China. Growth in its international arm has been uninspiring over recent years, but it is more profitable and means Tesco doesn’t have all its eggs in one basket. Its overseas operations generated less than 18% of revenue in 2018 but 21% of adjusted operating profit.
Tesco shows willingness to adapt by launching Jack’s
The supermarket has also shown a willingness to adapt by launching Jack’s, which is supposed to be a direct rival to Aldi and Lidl. Jack’s offers significantly fewer products than Tesco and is a much simpler offering. One of the reasons the German discounters have gained such an edge over the Big Four is because they have stripped back the offering and kept costs (and therefore prices) low. The average Aldi or Lidl (and now Jack’s) will have somewhere in the region of 2500 products on offer whilst a larger Tesco’s could have as many as 30,000.
Importantly, most products sold in Jack’s are Tesco’s own-label goods, which reinforces the idea that the company is focused on cutting out suppliers and increasing its control over the supply chain. Jack’s also places greater emphasis on ‘buying British’, claiming that eight out of ten products it sells are from the UK – which will no doubt be an advantage if importing food becomes more difficult post-Brexit.
It is early days for the concept, but it shows the direction Tesco is heading. Making more of its own products, sourcing more from the UK, improving its buying power and diversifying into wholesale should all support Tesco as it reacts to whatever Brexit throws at it.
Morrisons and Brexit
Morrisons is the smallest member of the Big Four but is seen to be in a much better position to tackle Brexit than its counterparts.
Morrison’s is a vertically-integrated business
It makes around 25% of everything it sells (including around half of its own-label produce), and it says about two-thirds of all its products are British.
The company is British farming’s single largest customer and the scale of its manufacturing operations makes it one of the largest producers of food in the country. All of its fresh meat, milk and eggs are British, and it also pushes the ‘buying local’ message in individual stores. Having such a prominent manufacturing and supply base in the UK will be a huge advantage for the supermarket amid Brexit. Although Morrisons will have to import certain products like everyone else, it is less exposed to the risk of tariffs and border checks.
Morrisons has been approved as Authorised Economic Operator
Morrisons started to take precautionary measures soon after the Brexit referendum and this has seen it become an Authorised Economic Operator, which means the company is recognised as a sound operator by the EU even after Brexit, which should reduce the risk of border checks on imported goods.
It is highly likely that border checks will be reintroduced if the UK leaves without a deal, and this will cause friction in existing supply chains. While this is inconvenient for any industry that imports from the EU, it poses a particular problem for supermarkets because they rely on thousands of deliveries of perishable goods every day, such as fruit and vegetables. The recent Yellowhammer Brexit paper – a government report outlining possible consequences under the ‘worst-case scenario’ – suggests there could be a two-day delay at ports.
If there are delays at the border, then the quality of the fresh produce being sold could deteriorate by having a shorter shelf-life. If this proves to be unmanageable and supermarkets choose not to stock items rather than run the risk of selling sub-par produce, then it could reduce the amount of choice for consumers.
The fact Morrisons sources more of its goods, including fresh produce, from the UK means it should be able to navigate this risk better than most, but the fact it has secured this certification also suggests its imported goods are at less risk after Brexit.
Morrison’s has diversified into wholesale
Morrisons has expanded into the wholesale market and has big ambitions. It generated around £700 million in wholesale revenue in the last financial year and is targeting annual sales of over £1 billion. It has now become a big supplier in both the UK and overseas. It supplies the likes of McColl’s convenience stores and is offered in several cities through Amazon. Internationally, it predominantly sells its own-label goods to Big C in Thailand.
Like Tesco, Morrisons wholesale arm not only gives it greater buying power but it is also a faster growing, higher-margin business to help offset the weak retail market.
Is Morrisons a takeover target?
Morrisons has long been touted as a potential takeover target, partly because of its relationship with Amazon. It recently adjusted a deal it had with Ocado that allowed it to expand its deal with Amazon into more UK cities and many consider Morrisons a logical target for the US giant if (or when) it decides to make its big entry into the UK grocery market. Hype around a potential acquisition of Morrisons, by Amazon or another party, has increased since the value of the pound has fallen in the wake of the Brexit referendum, which has made UK assets cheap to overseas investors.
Around 85% of Morrison’s real estate is owned under freehold, giving it a property portfolio to help support its valuation. Many believe the recent acquisition of pub chain Greene King was driven by its property portfolio (which looked a bargain compared to the share price) rather than the business itself.
Sainsbury’s and Brexit
Sainsbury’s has been shunned by investors since its attempted merger with rival Asda was blocked by regulators. The combination was meant to be the supermarket’s big response to Tesco buying Booker but was scuppered on competition concerns, and Sainsbury’s has yet to convince the market that it has a plan B.
With major mergers and acquisitions (M&A) seemingly ruled out, it has sensibly focused on shoring-up the balance sheet and improving its competitiveness on price. It is also investing in higher-growth areas like its bakery, food-on-the-go, and fresh food counters that sell the likes of fish and meat. Debt is being reduced and more is being invested in stores following criticisms of empty shelves and a lack of staff. But, with Tesco gaining huge scale, Morrison’s boasting a vertically-integrated business, and the threat of Amazon entering the market, many fear Sainsbury’s will be left behind. Some believe Sainsbury’s needs to act more than most because it sits in the middle of the market and has lost customers to both high-end brands like Waitrose as well as discounters Aldi and Lidl.
Sainsbury’s has also been somewhat more bearish than its rivals when it comes to Brexit. In March 2018, CEO Mike Coupe warned Sainsbury’s would ‘need somewhere around 12 to 15 months’ worth of notice to be able to adapt to whatever we need to adapt to’. However, he also said the supermarket was more practised after the Brexit deadline was pushed back twice.
Sainsbury’s is currently the best-performing ‘Big Four’ supermarket
Having said that, there are green shoots. It has been the best performing supermarket out of the Big Four for two months in a row, according to data from Kantar, and last month was its strongest performance for nearly a year. Kantar said this was because the supermarket had ‘increased its rate of sales on promotion faster than any other retailer with its Price Lockdown strategy lowering prices on meat and fresh produce in particular.’
Although Sainsbury’s has fallen out of favour, its recent performance suggests things could be improving. That could present an opportunity considering Sainsbury’s shares are down nearly one-third over the past year, 17% since the start of 2019 and down 14% over the past five years.
This information has been prepared by IG, a trading name of IG Markets Limited. In addition to the disclaimer below, the material on this page does not contain a record of our trading prices, or an offer of, or solicitation for, a transaction in any financial instrument. IG accepts no responsibility for any use that may be made of these comments and for any consequences that result. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of this information. Consequently any person acting on it does so entirely at their own risk. Any research provided does not have regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation and needs of any specific person who may receive it. It has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such is considered to be a marketing communication. Although we are not specifically constrained from dealing ahead of our recommendations we do not seek to take advantage of them before they are provided to our clients. See full non-independent research disclaimer and quarterly summary.
Trading around Brexit
Find out how the UK’s exit from the EU continues to affect traders, and discover:
- The unique opportunities in a ‘hard’ and ‘soft’ Brexit
- The markets you should be watching
- Everything that’s happened so far
Live prices on most popular markets