Trading and investing offer different types of exposure to the financial marketplace. In this guide, we’ll unpack how the two vary, including how features compare.
Trading is taking a position on financial market underlying’s without owning them; investing is taking outright ownership of financial assets. With us, you can trade derivatives via CFDs or invest directly in shares and ETFs through the IG Markets app.
Below are some key points of comparison between the two:
Trading
Investing
What is trading?
Trading means taking a position on the price of an asset without owning the asset itself, i.e. you’re only predicting how it will perform on the financial market. With us, you’d trade using CFDs, which are financial derivatives that enable you to get exposure to the full value of the position at a percentage of the cost.
As well as CFDs, traders can use other derivatives to access financial markets – such as options or futures contracts.
Without ownership, you can take a position on both rising (going long) and falling (going short) prices – either way, you’d make a profit if your prediction is correct. Going long means you’re predicting that the market price for that asset will rise, while going short means you believe that the asset will fall in value.
CFDs are leveraged, which means that you’d only put down an initial deposit to open a larger position. In essence, you’d borrow the difference between deposit and position value from the provider to make a bigger trade. With leverage, you can access larger positions with less capital. While leverage brings your initial outlay down significantly, it also amplifies both possible profits and losses – so it’s vital to manage your risk properly.
You can trade more than 13,000 markets with us. These include:
What is investing?
Investing is buying a financial asset, owning it outright, with the aim of making a profit down the line. For example, purchasing a company's shares in the expectation that its share price will appreciate in future.
As well as buying shares, investors might also buy funds – including ETFs – or bonds.
The full investment value needs to be committed upfront. This initial outlay also represents the full extent of risk involved, eg if a company goes bankrupt, with its share price dropping to zero, the entire capital amount would be on the line.
Potential for profit is exclusively linked to an appreciation in the asset’s value – so, going long is the only option. Going long represents a belief that the price of an asset will rise. In addition to the possibility of buying low and selling high, dividends are another way to potentially profit (in the case of equities). But some companies don’t pay dividends as there’s no obligation to do so.
Trading and investing differ characteristically, which affects various factors such as buying power, capital efficiency and how the outcome of the trade is determined.
Remember that, with us, you trade using CFDs and invest through the IG Markets app. Below are some important questions to consider when comparing trading and investing:
|
Trading |
Investing |
How to trade/invest with IG |
||
What markets can you access? |
- 13,000+ markets |
- Stocks and ETFs across global markets (US, UK, Singapore, Hong Kong, Japan) |
Will you own the asset? |
No |
Yes |
Do you get shareholder privileges and dividends? |
No shareholder privileges, but positions are adjusted to offset changes from dividends |
With shares and ETFs, you’ll receive dividends if they’re paid. Owning shares may also grant you voting rights in company decisions |
Can you go short? |
Yes, you can go short if you think prices will fall or long if you think prices will rise |
No – you're backing growth |
| Is the position leveraged? | Yes |
No |
| What's the deposit required to open a position? | Initial outlay for leveraged trades varies depending on the market and the total position size. With share CFDs, you'll also pay a small commission after opening the position |
You’ll pay the full value of your shares upfront. Zero commission. Zero platform fees |
| What's the timeframe? | Intra-day, short and medium term |
Medium to long term |
| Risks | Trades are leveraged, meaning you can lose substantially more than your initial outlay. Short-selling is also a complex strategy. Theoretically the risk is uncapped, as there's no limit to how much a market can rise |
No investment is guaranteed. You may get back less than invested, including losing your entire capital if the company fails. Past performance is not an indicator of future results |
| Risk management | Choose an automatic stop-loss level to try to limit potential losses. Negative balance protection, which is mandated by law, further limits potential losses |
Diversification, long-term horizon and US fractional shares to spread exposure |
| Platforms | Web-based platform, mobile app, MT4 (for selected CFD trades), ProRealTime for advanced, professional traders |
IG Markets app – built for mobile |
| Costs | The main charge when trading is in the spread, apart from share and ETF CFDs where it's commission |
Zero commission. Zero platform fees. Just FX conversion where applicable |
Ready to trade or invest?
| Shares | ETFs | |
| What it is | Choosing specific companies to invest in by buying stocks | A broad exposure financial instrument that tracks a whole group of stocks or even an industry or sector passively |
| Why you’d choose it | To buy a stake in companies you believe will rise in value and capitalise on the possible increase in share price by later selling your shares for a profit. Also, to receive any dividends payable and exercise shareholder rights in company decisions | To diversify investment into an industry or sector you believe in, to possibly make a profit from the positive growth of that whole group of stocks or industry |
| What we offer | Shares from global markets (US, UK, Singapore, Hong Kong, Japan) with US fractional shares from S$1 | Hundreds of ETFs spanning sectors, regions and strategies |
CFD trading
CFD stands for ‘contract for difference’ because you’re entering into an agreement to exchange the difference in an asset’s price between the time of your opening a position to the time of closing it.
With CFDs, you can go long or short depending on whether you think the market price will rise or fall. If your prediction is correct, the difference in price between your opening of the trade and your closing it is given to you in the form of profit. If your prediction is incorrect, you forfeit that difference instead as a loss.
To illustrate how CFD trading works, we’ve put together a brief example based on a position of 5000 Greenland shares.
| Trading (IG Trading) | Investing (IG Markets) | |
Share price |
$0.50 | $0.50 |
Our buy price |
$0.50 |
$0.50 |
You decide to |
Buy 5,000 shares |
Buy 5,000 shares |
Margin amount |
20% (example) |
N/A – full value paid upfront |
Initial outlay (in Singapore dollars) |
$500 |
$2,500 |
Commission |
$10 (example CFD commission) |
$0 |
Share price |
$0.60 |
$0.60 |
Our sell price |
$0.60 |
$0.60 |
| Difference from buy price at time of close |
$0.10 per share | $0.10 per share |
Your gross profit |
$500 | $500 |
| Value of full position | $3,000 | $3,000 |
| Cost to close | $10 (example CFD commission) | $0 |
| Your net profit or loss* | $480 |
$500 |
| Profit or loss as a percentage of the initial outlay |
96% | 20% |
The table is for illustrative purposes only.
How to take a position when investing
How to take a position when trading
Before you launch your trading journey, you need solid knowledge of the relevant fundamental concepts. Here are a few you need to know:
In trading, going long and going short are the terms for the two main directions a market can move in. You’ll go long (or ‘buy’, also known as being bullish) if you think that the underlying will appreciate in price. Going short or ‘shorting’ a market (also known as ‘selling’ or being bearish) is the reverse – taking a position with the belief that the asset price will decline.
You’ll make a profit or loss depending on whether your prediction is correct. In other words, you’ll make a profit going long if market prices rise, or you’ll lose money if they fall. When shorting a market, you’ll make a profit if its price depreciates, or you’ll incur a loss if it rises instead.
Remember, going short is an inherently risky strategy when trading, as your potential for loss is theoretically unlimited. This is because there’s no limit to how much an asset’s price can rise. So, ensure you always take steps to manage your risk.
Leverage is a feature that determines the way you open a position, how much you pay for it and how your losses are calculated – it enables you to open a larger position at only a fraction of the cost.
Unlike with investing, where you’d pay the full value of the trade upfront to buy that asset, leverage means you’d pay a small portion of the position’s worth upfront to take a position on the asset. When you close your trade for either a profit or loss, the calculation is based on the full position size, not the initial deposit you committed. Just as profits are payable to you, you’re solely liable for any losses.
Margin is the initial deposit amount required to open a leveraged trade. This amount is a percentage of the full position size and you are ‘borrowing’ the rest from the provider you’re using to trade.
The start of a solid foundation when investing is knowledge of the key concepts. Here are a few you need to know:
1. What’s a stock exchange?
A stock exchange is a centralised financial marketplace where assets such as shares and bonds are bought and sold for money. Just as you’d go to a marketplace to buy and sell goods like food or clothing, financial assets like shares and ETFs have marketplaces, too.
2. What are dividends?
Dividends are payments given to shareholders by the company they’ve bought shares in, which usually come out of company profits. Companies that do well financially are more likely to give dividends, or larger dividend payments, than ones that are struggling. However, some companies choose not to pay dividends to fund ventures such as product development or expansion.
It’s important to note that companies aren’t required to pay dividends, but may choose to. Some companies pay dividends regularly and predictably, for example each quarter, while others give ‘special’ dividends more sporadically and only if certain profit margins are met. In such cases, dividends can be regarded as ‘bonuses’ rather than primary source investment income.
Companies announce their dividends ahead of time. When a stock is ‘cum dividend’, it’s due to be paid out soon, on the specified ‘payment date’. Close to this time, that stock is ‘ex dividend’, meaning that payouts are imminent and, if you were to become a shareholder at this point in time, you’d only be eligible for the next dividend and onward.
3. What causes share prices to rise or fall?
Share price appreciation and depreciation are determined by a number of factors, both within the company itself and the wider market.
Different shares are worth different amounts of money. A share’s value will vary depending on whether you’re looking at its fair value or its market value. The fair value is the intrinsic value of a stock based on the company’s fundamentals, while the market value is the amount that individuals are currently willing to pay for the stock.
At its simplest level, share prices and the value of ETFs increase when the company or fund is performing well in the marketplace, is well managed and has support or popularity from the public. Events like the company’s latest earnings season or a high-profile press conference can spike or drop share prices temporarily.
Learn more about what moves share prices
However, no company or ETF is an island – and wider market conditions and sentiment can affect share prices, too. These factors include macroeconomic events (for instance, the Covid-19 pandemic affected almost every company and ETF globally), major geopolitical events in the country that the company or ETF is domiciled in, as well as news and fiscal decisions on interest rates and the like. If the company or ETF in question is linked to a certain industry, for instance mining, the supply and demand for resources from that industry will also materially affect the share price or ETF value.
What is right for me: trading or investing?
Whether you're more of a trader or more of an investor is determined by a number of factors. This could include your financial goals, the timeframes for those goals, your risk appetite, the capital you have available and your knowledge of the financial marketplace.
Generally (although not always), investing is best suited to those who have a long-term view and can wait months or even years to achieve their financial goals. It's also often used by those with a lower appetite for risk and with enough capital to pay full position sizes upfront.
Trading, on the other hand, is usually shorter-term than investing, with less upfront capital required. However, it does require more of a time commitment and willingness to watch markets regularly. Trading is often higher risk than investing and so is best suited to those with a greater appetite for taking risks.
Not sure whether you're a trader or investor? Don't worry – you can open both a trading account and an investment account with us, so you don't need to choose.
How can I open a trading account?
Once you’re ready, you can open a live trading account with us by filling in our application form. We’ll ask you a few questions about your trading experience and verify your identity (this takes place almost instantly in most cases). Then, you can fund your account and start trading.
How can I open an investment account?
Opening your IG Markets account is a straightforward process that gets you investing quickly:
Can I have more than one account?
Yes. You can have a CFD trading account on the IG platform and an IG Markets investing account on the app. Both can run simultaneously – just fund each separately.
What is a demo account?
We offer free a practice account, called a demo, to help you develop your CFD trading skills and gain confidence before opening a live account.
Opening a demo account with us is free and gives you access to a demo version of our live platform to familiarise yourself with it, plus $200,000 in virtual funds to practise trading with on the demo.
Where can I learn more about trading and investing?
With us, you get free access to educational resources to learn more about trading and investing. This includes IG Academy, where you can undertake courses in your own time at various skill levels, from the most basic concepts to advanced knowledge.
We also have a learning hub where you can explore trading guides, popular content, current events and more to help you stay informed.
Disclaimers: