Trading Brexit ‘winners’ isn’t paying off

We look at why investors need to be careful while trying to pick firms based on currency movements alone.

British flag
Source: Bloomberg

The slump in the pound after Brexit vote meant that a number of big UK-listed companies saw their share prices rally over the summer of 2016. But, as sterling surges in the wake of the election announcement, it looks like the strategy of simply picking firms based on their currency exposure has run its course.

To take a few examples, international firms like Compass, Imperial Brands, Diageo, Reckitt Benckiser and Unilever all rose after 23 June, gaining an average of 10.7% until the beginning of October 2016. But since the snap general election was announced, the five have moved in the range between -2% and +4%.

The problem with the idea of trading firms based on their currency exposure is that it is an imperfect method. It makes sense, as a market narrative, to argue that most, if not all, of the gains in the FTSE 100 came due to the weakness in the pound following the Brexit vote. Yet, other stock markets gained, even if not to the same extent. Instead, it is more accurate to note that sterling weakness helped the FTSE 100 to a significant extent, but did not cause the rally by itself as investor positioning had become bearish before the Brexit vote, and when the world did not come to an end after the referendum, we saw investors return to the market.

In addition, currency moves affect different companies to different extents. And firms will also make sure to report changes in revenues and profits in both unadjusted and adjusted (i.e. taking into account the currency movement) terms, so that investors can see how the currency impact has affected their performance. Thus, assuming that firms with big international exposure will be automatic winners is not a prudent approach. Currencies are a two-way street, and operations in some countries will be more affected than in others, especially if a currency traded against sterling has weakened even more than the pound has.

Finally, currency is only one element in a company’s performance. A host of other factors come into play, including relative valuation versus others in the sector, earnings history, dividend payments and so on. Excluding these means that investors are not getting the full picture, and thus are running greater risks. Currency is certainly a factor to be considered, but it is not the be all and end all.

Denne informasjonen har blitt forberedt av IG Europe GmbH og IG Markets Ltd (begge IG). I tillegg til disclaimeren nedenfor, inneholder ikke denne siden oversikt over kurser, eller tilbud om, eller oppfordring til, en transaksjon i noe finansielt instrument. IG påtar seg intet ansvar for handlinger basert på disse kommentarene og for eventuelle konsekvenser som et resultat av dette. Ingen garanti gis for nøyaktigheten eller fullstendigheten av denne informasjonen. Personer som handler ut i fra denne informasjonen gjør det på egen risiko. Forskning gitt her tar ikke hensyn til spesifikke investeringsmål, finansiell situasjon og behov som angår den enkelte person som mottar dette. Denne informasjonen er ikke utarbeidet i samsvar med regelverket for investeringsanalyser, så derfor er denne informasjonen ansett å være markedsføringsmateriale. Selv om vi ikke er hindret i å handle i forkant av våre anbefalinger, ønsker vi ikke å dra nytte av dem før de blir levert til våre kunder. Se fullstendig disclaimer og kvartalsvis oppsummering.

Finn artikler av analytikere

CFDer er komplekse instrumenter som innebærer stor risiko for raske tap på grunn av giring. 75 % av alle ikke-profesjonelle kunder taper penger på CFDer hos denne leverandøren. Du burde tenke etter om du forstår hvordan CFDer fungerer og om du har råd til den høye risikoen for å tape penger. Profesjonelle kunder kan tape mer enn sitt opprinnelige innskudd. Opsjoner og turbowarranter er komplekse finansielle instrument og du risikerer kapitalen din. CFDer er komplekse instrumenter som innebærer stor risiko for raske tap på grunn av giring.