SA retail industry outlook and results
Retailers battle weak consumer climate. This article looks at the performance of Mr Price Group, Woolworths Holdings, Truworths International and the Foschini Group for the 9 months to December 2018 and 2019 updates.
For the most part, it has been a dismal round of updates from locally listed retailers of clothing and apparel. A constrained consumer environment and delayed (stalling) turnaround strategies have weighed on the companies and reflected in their results. A summary of the salient features of the updates as well as commentary thereon is as follow:
Trading Update for Q3 2019 and the 9 months ended 29 December 2018
- Group retail sales & other income +5.8% (9 months)
- MRP Apparel +0.4% (3 months)
- MRP Sport +12.7% (3 Months)
- Miladys 0.2% (3 months)
- MRP Home +4.9% (3 months)
- Sheet Street +1% (3 months)
The Mr Price Group saw the clothing and apparel divisions under pressure in the third quarter of FY19, hampered by lower Black Friday sales which were impacted by the groups decision not to over discount and compromise margins for the event. There was a gross margin improvement for Mr Price in the third quarter, although the group now carries a high level of inventory moving into the final quarter of the financial year. A key focus for the group in Q4 2019 will be to clear the excess stock and so it appears unlikely that in the short term the improved margins alluded to can be maintained. MR P Sport was the standout performer within the group, managing to produce double digit growth over the reporting period.
The group expects a challenging 4th quarter of FY19. Trading on a price to earnings multiple of 18, we feel that the company may be expensive at current levels, trading ahead of fair value at present.
1H 2019 Sales update
- Headline earnings per share expected to be between 7.5% and 12.5% lower than prior years comparative period
- South Africa clothing sales -2%, food sales +6.3%
- David Jones sales +1%
- Country road Sales +2.3%
The 1H 2019 update came in below consensus estimates and were generally considered weak by the market. While the food division has managed to maintain above inflation growth, the higher margin SA clothing, David jones and Country Road businesses have all underperformed over the period to trade (more or less) flat against the prior years comparative period. The results reflect a constrained South African and Australian client and are suggestive that the turnaround strategy in these operations may take longer than was originally expected.
While Woolworths offers an attractive dividend yield of nearly 5% (historic), contracting earnings suggest that trading on a P/E of 14x might be a challenging multiple for the group to maintain.
1H 2019 Trading Update
- Retail sales +2%
- Credit sales +3.7%
- Cash sales +0.3%
- Retail sales for Truworths Africa +2.4%
- Retail Sales for UK operations +0.8% (rand terms)
- Headline earnings per share expected 5% to 7% lower
Relatively flat sales growth and lower earnings show contracting margins for Truworths International over the 6 months to December 2018. While Sales in the group’s UK operations increased by 0.8% in rand terms, in Stirling terms this was actually a 3% contraction. The UK Office business remains the challenge for the group and will need to show signs of moving towards profitability to appease investor sentiment going forward.
The update for Truworths, although weak does see the group to be slightly ahead of it peers Mr Price and Woolworths in terms of sales relating to clothing and apparel.
Trading Update for the 9 months to December 2018
- Consolidated turnover +22.7%
- TFG African turnover +9.5%
- TFG London turnover +3.5%
- TFG Australia comparable turnover +15.6%
The Foschini Group update has exceeded analyst expectations, leading sales growth amongst its sector peers. London sales growth is well ahead of Truworths, while its Australian sales growth has dwarfed that of Woolworths and its African turnover growth Is more than 60% quicker than that of Mr Price (in the last 9 months).
While we feel that retailers of clothing and apparel remain in a difficult consumer landscape at present, recent updates would suggest that The Foschini is perhaps the best in class right now.
This information has been prepared by IG, a trading name of IG Markets Limited. In addition to the disclaimer below, the material on this page does not contain a record of our trading prices, or an offer of, or solicitation for, a transaction in any financial instrument. IG accepts no responsibility for any use that may be made of these comments and for any consequences that result. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of this information. Consequently any person acting on it does so entirely at their own risk. Any research provided does not have regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation and needs of any specific person who may receive it. It has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such is considered to be a marketing communication. Although we are not specifically constrained from dealing ahead of our recommendations we do not seek to take advantage of them before they are provided to our clients. See full non-independent research disclaimer and quarterly summary.
Live prices on most popular markets